Menu Close

What-is-the-minimum-value-of-x-y-z-subject-to-the-condition-xyz-a-




Question Number 138004 by benjo_mathlover last updated on 09/Apr/21
  What is the minimum value of x+y+z, subject to the condition xyz = a³?
What is the minimum value of x+y+z, subject to the condition xyz = a³?
Answered by EDWIN88 last updated on 09/Apr/21
AM−GM   for x, y, z ≥ 0 ⇒ ((x+y+z)/3) ≥ ((xyz))^(1/3)  ; x+y+z ≥ 3 (a^3 )^(1/3)   minimum x+y+z = 3a
AMGMforx,y,z0x+y+z3xyz3;x+y+z3a33minimumx+y+z=3a
Answered by bobhans last updated on 09/Apr/21
f(x,y,z,λ)=x+y+z+λ(xyz−a^3 )  (∂f/∂x) = 1+λyz=0  (∂f/∂y)=1+λxz = 0  (∂f/∂z)=1+λxy=0  ⇔ −(1/(yz))=−(1/(xz))=−(1/(xy))  we get xy=xz=yz ; x=y=z  from condition xyz = a^3   we get x=y=z=a  minimum x+y+z = 3a
f(x,y,z,λ)=x+y+z+λ(xyza3)fx=1+λyz=0fy=1+λxz=0fz=1+λxy=01yz=1xz=1xywegetxy=xz=yz;x=y=zfromconditionxyz=a3wegetx=y=z=aminimumx+y+z=3a
Commented by mr W last updated on 09/Apr/21
how to explain this example:  a=1  x=−10, y=−(1/(10)), z=1  xyz=(−10)(−(1/(10)))(1)=1=a^3   but x+y+z=−10−(1/(10))+1=−9(1/(10))<3a=3  i.e. 3a is not minimum
howtoexplainthisexample:a=1x=10,y=110,z=1xyz=(10)(110)(1)=1=a3butx+y+z=10110+1=9110<3a=3i.e.3aisnotminimum
Commented by mr W last updated on 09/Apr/21
i think x+y+z has no minimum or  maximum under the condition that  xyz=a^3 .
ithinkx+y+zhasnominimumormaximumundertheconditionthatxyz=a3.
Commented by mr W last updated on 09/Apr/21
i just wanted to show that x=y=z  doesn′t lead to minimum of x+y+z.  with x=−10 it is only an example.  i can also take an other example:  x=1, y=−100, z=−(1/(100)). i fulfill  xyz=1=a^3   but x+y+z=−99(1/(100)) which is smaller  than the minimum 3a=3 you calculated.
ijustwantedtoshowthatx=y=zdoesntleadtominimumofx+y+z.withx=10itisonlyanexample.icanalsotakeanotherexample:x=1,y=100,z=1100.ifulfillxyz=1=a3butx+y+z=991100whichissmallerthantheminimum3a=3youcalculated.
Commented by bobhans last updated on 09/Apr/21
why you get x=−10? from λ it  clear x=y=z
whyyougetx=10?fromλitclearx=y=z

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *