Menu Close

Ten-balls-were-manufactured-nine-of-them-have-the-same-mass-while-just-one-of-them-has-a-slightly-higher-or-slightly-lower-mass-Given-is-just-a-beam-balance-and-no-weights-comparing-the-masses-of




Question Number 16450 by ajfour last updated on 22/Jun/17
Ten balls were manufactured,   nine of them have the same  mass, while just one of them  has a slightly higher or slightly  lower mass. Given is just a beam  balance and no weights. comparing  the masses of balls only, with the  help of the balance , and in just  3 weighings explain how to judge  which is the defective one and  whether it is heavier or lighter  than the rest (as the case may be).
Tenballsweremanufactured,nineofthemhavethesamemass,whilejustoneofthemhasaslightlyhigherorslightlylowermass.Givenisjustabeambalanceandnoweights.comparingthemassesofballsonly,withthehelpofthebalance,andinjust3weighingsexplainhowtojudgewhichisthedefectiveoneandwhetheritisheavierorlighterthantherest(asthecasemaybe).
Commented by prakash jain last updated on 22/Jun/17
10 balls=b_1 ,...,b_(10)   set A=b_1 ,b_2 ,b_3   set B=b_4 ,b_5 ,b_6   set C=b_7 ,b_8 ,b_9   2 weighs compare A&B and A&C   case 1: A=B=C          b_(10)  is fault.          measure b_(10)  with b_1  to find out          if b_(10)  is heavier to lighter.  case 2: one of group is unequal          at we know the defective set          and whether it is heavier to lighter          than the other. Let us say set is A.          compare b_1  and b_2  if equal b_3  is defectivd            if equal b_3  is defectivd            if not equal the heavier or lighter            ball is defective. (we already               identified the nature of defecr)
10balls=b1,,b10setA=b1,b2,b3setB=b4,b5,b6setC=b7,b8,b92weighscompareA&BandA&Ccase1:A=B=Cb10isfault.measureb10withb1tofindoutifb10isheaviertolighter.case2:oneofgroupisunequalatweknowthedefectivesetandwhetheritisheaviertolighterthantheother.LetussaysetisA.compareb1andb2ifequalb3isdefectivdifequalb3isdefectivdifnotequaltheheavierorlighterballisdefective.(wealreadyidentifiedthenatureofdefecr)
Commented by prakash jain last updated on 22/Jun/17
Extension: How many measurement are required  if there are 3n+1 balls and  1 is defective.
Extension:Howmanymeasurementarerequiredifthereare3n+1ballsand1isdefective.
Commented by ajfour last updated on 23/Jun/17
 Great solving sir, good noticing   ability. Thanks.
Greatsolvingsir,goodnoticingability.Thanks.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *