Question and Answers Forum

All Questions      Topic List

Arithmetic Questions

Previous in All Question      Next in All Question      

Previous in Arithmetic      Next in Arithmetic      

Question Number 198321 by necx122 last updated on 17/Oct/23

A certain preliminary science class  contains 50 students all of whom take  Mathematics. 18 study Chemistry, 17  study Biology, 24 study Physics. Of  those taking three subjects, 5 study  Physics and Chemistry, 7 study Physics  and Biology and 6 study Chemistry  and Biology while 2 take all four subjects.  How many students study only Mathematics?

Acertainpreliminaryscienceclasscontains50studentsallofwhomtakeMathematics.18studyChemistry,17studyBiology,24studyPhysics.Ofthosetakingthreesubjects,5studyPhysicsandChemistry,7studyPhysicsandBiologyand6studyChemistryandBiologywhile2takeallfoursubjects.HowmanystudentsstudyonlyMathematics?

Commented by necx122 last updated on 17/Oct/23

This is another question that troubled me. please help me with the Venn diagram and the solution . Thanks in advance.

Answered by mr W last updated on 17/Oct/23

Commented by mr W last updated on 17/Oct/23

13 study only mathematics.

13studyonlymathematics.

Commented by necx122 last updated on 17/Oct/23

Thank you sir. I really understand this but the textbook says the answer is 7 students.

Commented by mr W last updated on 17/Oct/23

then textbook is wrong.

thentextbookiswrong.

Commented by necx122 last updated on 17/Oct/23

Ok sir. I actually believe your solving than my textbooks however. After seeing your Venn diagram and the answer you got I resubstituted the values and got 7. I substituted it such that the intersection between each of biology and physics only, biology and chemistry only and chemistry and physics only to reduce by 2. Thus giving us 5 , 4 and 3. Yet, I'll want to agree with you sir. Thank you.

Commented by deleteduser1 last updated on 18/Oct/23

The answer should be 7.

Theanswershouldbe7.

Commented by mr W last updated on 18/Oct/23

can you please show the corresponding  venn diagram?

canyoupleaseshowthecorrespondingvenndiagram?

Commented by deleteduser1 last updated on 18/Oct/23

We can also use the formula in the answer   below.

Wecanalsousetheformulaintheanswerbelow.

Commented by mr W last updated on 18/Oct/23

according to question:  of those taking three subjects, 5 study  physics and chemistry.  but according to your venn diagram  only 3 study physics and chemistry.

accordingtoquestion:ofthosetakingthreesubjects,5studyphysicsandchemistry.butaccordingtoyourvenndiagramonly3studyphysicsandchemistry.

Commented by deleteduser1 last updated on 18/Oct/23

3+2=5, we add the 2 from P,C and B.  3 take Physics and Chemistry only, but 3+2=5  take Physics and Chemistry.

3+2=5,weaddthe2fromP,CandB.3takePhysicsandChemistryonly,but3+2=5takePhysicsandChemistry.

Commented by mr W last updated on 18/Oct/23

but the 2 students take all four subjects,  so they are not those taking three   subjects.

butthe2studentstakeallfoursubjects,sotheyarenotthosetakingthreesubjects.

Commented by mr W last updated on 18/Oct/23

i only accept the answer of the textbook,  if in the question the underlined  sentence doesn′t exist, or if it is  of those taking at least three subjects.

ionlyaccepttheanswerofthetextbook,ifinthequestiontheunderlinedsentencedoesntexist,orifitisofthosetakingatleastthreesubjects.

Commented by deleteduser1 last updated on 18/Oct/23

My solution below is also another way to look  at it.

Mysolutionbelowisalsoanotherwaytolookatit.

Commented by mr W last updated on 18/Oct/23

at first i solved exactly like you, then  i changed my mind due to the  sentence “of those taking three   subjects, ....”.   anyway i think the answer 7 in textbook   is wrong, if we strictly follow the   text in the question.

atfirstisolvedexactlylikeyou,thenichangedmymindduetothesentenceofthosetakingthreesubjects,.....anywayithinktheanswer7intextbookiswrong,ifwestrictlyfollowthetextinthequestion.

Commented by deleteduser1 last updated on 18/Oct/23

2 take all subjects imply 2 take Physics,  Chemistry and Biology.

2takeallsubjectsimply2takePhysics,ChemistryandBiology.

Commented by mr W last updated on 18/Oct/23

and mathematics as well, since all  students in the class study   mathematics.

andmathematicsaswell,sinceallstudentsintheclassstudymathematics.

Commented by deleteduser1 last updated on 18/Oct/23

Yes, but we are considering P,B and C like in  the answer below.  We find the total number that take P,B or C,  which is 43. This means there are 50−43=7 that  do no take any of P,B or C.So,the remaining  take Maths only.

Yes,butweareconsideringP,BandClikeintheanswerbelow.WefindthetotalnumberthattakeP,BorC,whichis43.Thismeansthereare5043=7thatdonotakeanyofP,BorC.So,theremainingtakeMathsonly.

Commented by necx122 last updated on 18/Oct/23

Thank you very much sir. These comments have helped me understand the question properly. Thank you.

Answered by deleteduser1 last updated on 18/Oct/23

∣PuBuC∣=∣P∣+∣B∣+∣C∣−∣PnB∣−∣BnC∣−∣PnC∣  +∣PnBnC∣⇒∣PuBuC∣=18+17+24−5−7−6+2  =43  ⇒∣Maths only∣=50−43=7

PuBuC∣=∣P+B+CPnBBnCPnC+PnBnC∣⇒∣PuBuC∣=18+17+24576+2=43⇒∣Mathsonly∣=5043=7

Terms of Service

Privacy Policy

Contact: info@tinkutara.com